Relentlessly Progressive Economics |
Privacy and the Census: It’s Really Not All About You
Are there good alternatives to the mandatory census long-form questionnaire to collect the information that we need?
Last Saturday CBC’s The House had a sparkling section on the census which offered some thoughts from a Danish statistician and the views of Canada’s longest serving Chief Statistician, Ivan Fellegi. On Tuesday Tavia [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Staples Recovery
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) edged up 0.1% in May. Annualized output was $1,231 billion, still below the pre-crisis peak of $1,241 billion in July 2008 but well above the trough of $1,186 billion in May 2009.
Canada-US Comparison
American GDP figures released this morning indicate an annual growth rate of 2.4% in the second quarter (April - [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Stanbury on Coercion
Professor Emeritus at University of British Columbia, William Stanbury, has produced a handy treatise on coercion, published online in the Hill Times this week. Stanbury focused his career as a professor of economics on strategic decision-making in business, including government relations, competition rules, regulations and other public policies that strengthen business performance.
His [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
The Western Climate Initiative: another baby step
It has been a while but this week climate change is back in the news cycle. The front page of today’s Globe reports on the latest climate impacts tally:
The report … concluded 2000 to 2009 was the warmest decade ever, and the Earth has been growing warmer for 50 years. Each of the past three [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
An Exit Strategy for the Conservatives
Anybody that has been watching the unfolding of the census dust-up could be forgiven for no longer knowing where to place their bets. Are the Conservatives really going to go through with this disruptive measure, or are there still ways out? The answer is yes, a successful resolution is still possible (read on). [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Can the provinces fix the Census Fiasco?
Once again Stephen Harper has charted a course for the nation that drops the ball in the provinces’ and territories’ lap.
Since forming government in 2006, the Harper Conservatives have withdrawn federal presence from social policy, health policy, and climate change while ramping up defence, security and trade. The cut to the GST [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Canada’s Productivity Problem
Back in June, the TD Economics group released a major report co-authored by Don Drummond: “The Productivity Puzzle. ” It provides a comprehensive overview of major studies and the empirical evidence, and should help spark some critical reflection. Progressive economists should agree with Drummond that productivity growth is vitally important to the growth of living [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Reflections on The Spirit Level
The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better, by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett, is an important book. It is not a huge tome, as one might expect from such a broad topic, weighing in at just 265 pages of text (including lots of figures mapping inequality against some health and social [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
National Statistics Council on the Census
The following statement was released this morning. The key point is that the mandatory long form census should remain for 2011, and some changes are proposed moving forward including removing the never-used penalty of prison for non compliance.
Seeking Solutions
The National Statistics Council, the senior, external advisory group appointed by the government of Canada to advise [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Will the Real Stephen Harper Please Stand Up?
Stephen Harper’s 1991 master’s thesis used census data to make his case about “political business cycles” and he even noted how disruptive changes in methodology could be for long-term analysis in understanding how Canadian political behaviour changed over time.
He ran a model to show the links between variables such as unemployment and changes in [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Carney on Business Investment: You Read It Here First
Nine days ago, I posted about private non-financial corporations accumulating cash rather than investing in Canada. A week later, the Bank of Canada’s Monetary Policy Report (MPR) noted “the relatively high level of liquidity held by the non-financial corporate sector and weak investment” (page 19).
By my count, the document expresses concern eight separate times about anemic [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Tempests in a Libertarian Teapot
The Macdonald-Laurier Institute, which has been leading the charge against mostly unidentified “inter-provincial trade barriers,” is now posting complaints about the “intrusive” census long form.
Are different-sized cream containers in various provinces and having to spend 20 minutes filling out a form once every couple of decades really the worst problems facing libertarians in Canada? If [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Debating Interprovincial Trade
Over at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Robert Knox has tried to rebut my rebuttal of his C. D. Howe Institute paper. (I am still waiting for a rebuttal of my rebuttal of his more recent Macdonald-Laurier Institute paper.)
Knox’s post sheds light on how his side of the debate sees the issue. But I begin with the [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
A Business POV and Direct Link to Clement’s Use of Census Long-Form Data
A highly regarded economist and business consultant sent me a link to his view of the significance and consequence of the Government’s decision to axe the census long-form questionnaire.
Elegantly concise and to the point, it reads like a cheat sheet for an exam on why Census long-form information is important, from the on-the-ground [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
The Politicization of the Public Service - Warning from a Former Clerk of the Privy Council
The resignation of Chief Statistician Munir Sheik has far-reaching political consequences, and may be the game-changer in this ongoing census saga.
But it is the extreme conclusion of a far more serious and consequential development - the politicization of the public service.
Read Alex Himelfarb on the topic, a former Clerk of the Privy Council (Canada’s top [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Essential Reading on the Census
A great piece of political analysis by Paul Saurette of Ottawa U - from the Mark
http://www.themarknews.com/articles/1907-when-smart-parties-make-stupid-decisions?page=1
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Inflation: The 1% Menace?
Between May and June, consumer prices decreased in both absolute and seasonally-adjusted terms. As a result, the annual inflation rate fell to 1.0%, about half what it had been at the start of this year.
One province, Manitoba, actually slipped into deflation. The Bank of Canada’s core rate edged down to 1.7%.
Monetary Policy
Inflation’s continuing decline begs [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
After the Fall - What’s Next for the Census?
There aren’t many stories like this one.
You have to go back half a century, to Diefenbaker and Coyne, to find a parallel. Then too, a Prime Minister increasingly viewed as overly controlling insisted on an unworkable policy until the Governor of the Bank of Canada had no choice but to step down, in an attempt [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
Marc’s Summer Reading
With summer comes a lightening of my work load, so I’ve finally found some time to dive into a few interesting books. These are all related to my ongoing research interests (I do have some fiction sitting around waiting for a real holiday, with Barbara Kingsolver’s The Lacuna at the top of the pile):
The Story [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour
More Unemployment = More EI
For the first time in eight months, the number of Employment Insurance (EI) recipients increased in May. We already knew from the Labour Force Survey that unemployment had increased by just over 8,000 in May. It is good news that EI expanded by the same amount because it implies that those who became unemployed that [...]
Categories: All, Blogs By Labour

